Monday, October 27, 2008

The Ties That Bind

When one thinks of the phrase “the ties that bind”, many different thoughts come to mind. In the course of our lifetimes, we all become bound by invisible chains that bind us to people, places and things. These ties can either help us or hurt us depending on the situation. For example, one could reasonably argue that the first lines in the Constitution are words, or rather, ties that bind the American people in a common cause "….. in order to form a more perfect union, establish justice, insure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America." To me, these words are about the ties that bind the American people, not twist the fundamental fabric of our Nation, yet I have been told again and again over the past year that I have no rights in regards to the Mashpee Wampanoag Land in Trust process. I have no say in what happens in my community and all I can think is….why? Having been witness to the so called process of Land in Trust as it has unfolded here in our small corner of the world, I wonder about those words written in the Constitution and I wonder about the written words of the Tribe itself…the words, or ties that bind them, and where those ties bind them.

So I find myself still arguing about the Mashpee Wampanoag’s claims to significant historical ties to land in a Town that I don’t even live in. I am speaking out because our Constitution gives me that right even if the land in trust process doesn't. But why even bother, right? I mean, they were here first so who am I to say they don’t have significant historical ties to Middleboro? All I can say to that is, I am an American citizen who happens to believe in life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness for all…and I just so happen to be someone who has read the Tribe’s Final Determination..you know, the evidence they used to gain Federal Recognition, and are now using in their mad dash attempt to build a casino on land they have no right calling an “initial reservation”. The enhancements in the Section 20 regulations clearly and distinctly define the requirements for significant historical ties to land being sought as an initial reservation. In reading the Federal Register to learn about the new regulations I quickly realized that they are written so clearly that even your average citizen – John Q. Public – can understand and follow what the Federal Government is requiring for proof of significant historical ties to land.

When talking about “significant historical ties”, aren’t we really talking about a cultural landscape? I am talking about a landscape created by humans in the natural world, one that reveals fundamental ties between people and the land – ties based on the basic human need to grow food, give form to settlements, to provide recreation and even suitable places to bury our dead….our cultural landscape that we call home. In the case of the Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe, claiming the land in Middleboro as their own is more than just saying “I was here first”…it is about demonstrating that the Mashpee Wampanoag Tribal ancestors lived on the land in Middleboro, had a burial ground on the land in Middleboro or hunted the land in Middleboro to feed their tribal members. This is about significant historical ties to the land, which according to their own Final Determination that was submitted as part of the application, there are none. There is no documented evidence that the Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe has significant historical ties to the land in Middleboro. But there is evidence that it belonged to another Tribe…..but that is not why I am writing this. I am writing this because I want to clarify why we say the Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe does not have significant historical ties to the land in Middleboro…why they are not bound to Middleboro, but to Mashpee.

If we could, let us take a moment and examine the Tribe’s trust application through the eyes of the Secretary of the Interior and look for evidence of the Tribe’s significant history to the land in Middleboro. In order to do this, we need to look at the Tribe’s Final Determination, which as I stated, was included in the trust application. But first, let’s clarify the significance of the Final Determination to the Tribe itself.

In order to receive Federal acknowledgement as an Indian tribe, the following seven (mandatory) criteria had to be applicable and demonstrated in the Tribes Final Determination:

1. The tribe has been identified as an American Indian entity on a substantially continual basis since 1900.

2. A predominant portion of the tribe comprises a distinct community and has existed as a community from historical times until the present.

3. The tribe has maintained political influence or authority over its members as an autonomous entity from historical times to the present

4. The tribe must provide a copy of the group’s present governing document including its membership criteria. In the absence of a written document, the tribe must provide a statement describing in full its membership criteria and current governing procedures.

5. The tribe’s membership must consist of individuals who descend from a historical Indian tribe or from historical Indian tribes which combined and functioned as a single autonomous political entity.

6. None of the tribe’s members can be part of any other federally acknowledged Indian tribe.

7. The tribe nor its members cannot be the subject of a congressional legislation that has expressly terminated or forbidden the federal relationship.

The first requirement regarding their existence as a tribe since 1900 is accomplished mostly through newspaper or magazine articles that mention the tribe. The next four requirements are important because of what they show in the way of the Tribe’s history and geography. The last two items on this list requires no action from the Tribe as it’s the Federal Governments’ job to check these out.

When the Federal Government acknowledged the Mashpee tribe, they provided a summary of the evidence they had considered. Because there are so many details in the summary itself, I have abbreviated the comments so as to focus only on the geographical references and how these references pertain to the Tribe’s significant historical ties to Middleboro….or more accurately, how they don’t……

Distinct Community

“….since first contact to the present day they comprised a distinct community from non-members in and around the Town of Mashpee.”

“….almost all of the Mashpee lived in a defined geographical area, the Town of Mashpee.”

“….defined geographical area comprised almost exclusively of their members, while those who lived elsewhere usually did so on a temporary basis….”

“….those few who lived elsewhere were very close by in adjacent communities….”

“….few Mashpee who lived outside of the town, often in adjacent towns or other areas of Cape Cod, maintained contact with those in town as evidenced through a high rate of return migration.”

“….concentrated residential patterns indicating that a significant part of the group still lived in an exclusive settlement in the Town of Mashpee.”

“….residency patterns were good evidence of community.”

“….significant number of members living within or very near the group’s traditional location in the center of the Town of Mashpee.”

Political Influence

“….political control of the Town of Mashpee….”

“….evidence of the Mashpee’s residential patterns….was also sufficient to demonstrate political influence.”

“….gave the Mashpee greater self-government by establishing an “Indian District” in Mashpee, Massachusetts.”

“….as part of an Indian District….the Mashpee gained complete control of political, legal, and economic affairs in the town...”

“….Mashpee adapted the principal elements of the town governmental system….”

Criteria for Membership

“….'near Mashpee' means having a residence within 20 miles of Mashpee.”

Descended from a Historical Tribe

“….historical Indian tribe was the Wampanoag Indians residing at Mashpee, Barnstable County…”

“….88 percent of the petitioner’s members descended from the historical Mashpee tribe…”

“….petitioner submitted evidence that 97 percent of its members descended from the historical tribe…”


(Note: this number increased when new records were produced after the preliminary report was compiled).

I have two personal favorites from this list:

The first being the Tribe requiring their members to live near Mashpee….within 20 miles of Mashpee to be exact. Middleboro is definitely within 20 miles of Mashpee, right? Ummmmm….weelll…. it is if you fold the map like one of those back pages from a Mad Magazine. Remember those? First there is the original picture but you could fold the page and it would become another (usually more comical) picture. Yeah, it’s just like that. A quick fold here….and viola!



Or, perhaps they meant 20 miles as the crow flies….or a flying monkey…

I also love that the Tribe’s current members must be descendants of a historical tribe and in this case, the Federal Government defines historical tribe as ‘the Wampanoag Indians residing at Mashpee, Barnstable County”. Yet the Tribe is trying to claim significant historical ties to Middleboro. Really….I couldn’t make up stuff this amusing!

Here are some more fun facts from the Final Determination:

The number of times Mashpee is mentioned: 265
(this number does not include the footnotes or page headings)

The number of time Middleboro is mentioned: 0
(this number does include the footnotes or page headings)

So if I was reading this from the Secretary of the Interior’s point of view, I would have to conclude based on the Tribe’s own Final Determination, the Mashpee Wampanoag Indian Tribe has significant historical ties to Mashpee….not to Middleboro. In fact, Middleboro is so insignificant, it wasn’t even mentioned at all in the Final Determination – yet the Tribe wants to claim significant historical ties after the fact so they can build a casino that happens to have a resort attached to it. Well, all I can say here is that the ties that bind have bound this Tribe not to Middleboro at all -- but to Mashpee alone. Claiming significant historical ties to the land in Middleboro at this point is nothing short of a hysterical attempt to try and hold onto the casino pipedream.

So if you were reading the Final Determination through the eyes of the Secretary of the Interior and trying to make a decision that will affect an entire region and making that decision in order to form a more perfect union, establish justice, insure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity….and ensure fairness to both the Tribe and the surrounding community, I must ask dear reader…… do you see any significant hysterical…..eeerrr….historical ties that bind the Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe to Middleboro?


“Bound by hundreds of ties of desire and enslaved by lust and anger; they strive to obtain wealth by unlawful means for the fulfillment of desires.” - Bhagavad Gita


- be the change you want to see in the world -

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

Well done, CC!

Anonymous said...

Yeah, but...

If they own the land now, and maybe build a house or two (or how ever many it takes to make a village) then they could, at some point in the future, make a claim for historical ties to Middleboro.

I can see the sign now:

Mashpee Wampanoag Indian Bingo Hall. Opening in Spring 3012.

(Cause in 3012, we are still keeping MA casino free!!!)

Here's CC, yet again giving me another reason to sleep easy at night. Great job. Thanks!!

Anonymous said...

CC, don't be ridiculous. Just because they are called the Mashpee Wampanoag's Indian tribe doesn't mean they are from Mashpee...huh?...what?...the federal government said so?

Never mind.

Anonymous said...

Do you ever sleep??

PLEASE, someone send this to that nice but very uninformed reporter, (have to mention him as I heard him speak the last night and am amazed, seems he believes everthing he reads from one book) and any other reporters that don't do their own research and if their not doing it, at least pay attention to the real research workers that are! If your going to repeat at least repeat from someone like carverchick that does intensive studying on the Land into Trust and gaming process and backs it up!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

We can count on you as usual carverchick to give us the real information and more importantly the why's, Thank you.

Now, anyone have that nice but uninformed reporters email address?? You know the one I mean.

Anonymous said...

My family is from the very small town of Cotuit on Cape Cod. We always knew the Mashpee Wamponoag's were not one, single, tribe. The Mashpee Wamponoag's are a tribe made up of many different individual Indians from other tribes, individuals that have come and gone over the years, more commin now with them hopefull for a casino, for I know of another tribe on the cape that has lost most of it's tribal members to the "new" Mashpee Wamponoag Tribe due to they might be in for some "big" money!

Some history for you off cape people, Mashpee Wamponoag's are a praying community in Mashpee, your town of Middleboro? if any claims are to be made for it, your town officals are backing the wrong tribe!!! But wait, I read and hear their not interested in history, they fell into the casino "backers" trap!!

For what it's worth, and for what I do know, my faith is in your information carverchick!! Keep it commin!!

Raymond Tolosko said...

You just hit the bullseye....incredible post.

Gladys Kravitz said...

There was no interest from Mashpee in Middleboro until Harvard pinpointed it as a prime place to capture the most potential gamblers.

The Mashpee have been seeking recognition well before reservation shopping became a national phenomenon. For them, in the beginning, Federal recognition was a source of pride. (Ok and some State funding...)

Thanks to some unscrupulous lawyers and bad legislation, which ironically actually had Native American's best interest at heart, recognition became less about pride and culture and more about casinos and greed. The corruption of Mashpee Tribal government, and the Tribe's manipulation by investors and their minions, is a symptom of greed, not pride, gone wild.

A fascinating, thoughtful and well-written blog post! Kudos!

Anonymous said...

Great stuff CC.

I was begining to think the Middleboro BOS had Wamapnoag blood?

Middleboro leadership is a joke.
I thought the New TM would give those monkeys some knowledge, but it looks like he is eating their bananas???

Middleboro BOS needs to be changed.
Then the new BOS can say

"NO CASINO" as should have been done in the 1st place.

Anonymous said...

Tribe 4 sale???

That is all it is.